George is the name of the character that kills his friend. Slim then asks why Lennie and George go around together because most of the ranch hands he's seen are always alone and "[n]ever seem to give a damn about nobody." George didn’t want this to happen to Lennie so he shoots Lennie because it is a quick way and Lennie died happily as George was talking about dream while he killed Lennie. George killed Lennie after Lennie accidentally killed Curley’s wife.George and Lennie had known eachother for a long time they even traveled together. George has made the wrong decision for killing Lennie. Another reason why Lennie Small was not able to stop himself from killing Curley’s wife is his mental fixation with rabbits. Gravity. recently shot Lennie Small in the back of his head, instantly killing him. George feels justified in killing Lennie because he knows that in the long run he would be able to spare many other lives and prevent Lennie from all the pain and anguish from the … Why do you think he uses this language? Despite Lennie being confused easily he is sure of his friendship "ain't nobody goin' to no hurt to George. " George killing Lennie is very immoral because Lennie does not know any better. Learn. PLAY. Candy thinks that he should of killed the dog and not some stranger and … Like, after Slim gives Lennie a puppy Lennie brings the puppy into the bunkhouse with him even though George told him he was not supposed to. Lennie was not like a sick animal that was suffering and needed to be put down, he was a human being. Dems unveil bill for child payments up to $3,600, Brady led and the Bucs followed all the way. George’s decision to kill Lennie prevented him from the possible verdict of a mental institution. He knows George is going to be mad, and he thinks George won't let him tend the rabbits. He had reasons to be killed, but who knows if that’s the reasons George had for killing Lennie. One reason why George isn’t guilty is because he is responsible for Lennie and always does right by him. George and Lennie were best friends ever since they were little. He believes that he is doing this for the sake of others but his decision if immoral. 3) You could draw a parallell to the killing of Lennie by George and the killing of Candy's dog by Candy. Why do the men think it's best to kill the dog? Or do you think he did it for self-gain, like he was tired of having to deal with Lennie? 6 in the novel. He searches out the dead mouse that George threw away. 1. They may never know if there could have been . Terms in this set (6) Quote 1 "I ought of shot that dog myself George, I shouldn't ought to let no stranger shoot my dog" Quote 2 "Curley's gonna want to shoot him. get 141 wilts, he’s deputy sheriff”. Also Slim had said that if for some reason they did find lennie and took him alive that it would be no good for him to be locked up in some room. He is forced to kill Lennie for his own good. A foreshadowing of the need for Lennie to be killed by George is when Cady says to George, “I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. 6. An important theme in Of Mice and Men is the controversy of euthanasia, which is killing people out of pity. Notice that a crippled black man, who may be lower in status, Of Mice and Men Socratic Seminar Responses to Questions What are the three reasons that george Milton is not guilty after killing Lennie small? George and Lennie are migrant workers that struck a job in California. The Lost Portion of Human Society Spell. Proving the unjustified death of Lennie. ...all charges brought upon George Milton. Lennie could have been charged with rape on two separate occasions. He also prevents Lennie from suffering a miserable fate. Test. When she started to complain, he panicked. After the pandemic is over, will unemployment soar? For example, after Lennie comes into the bunkhouse, The Four Main Causes Of Coagulation In Drinking Water. Reasons Why George Was Justified In Of Mice And Men 702 Words | 3 Pages. Curley's still mad about his hand. The reason he repeats this is because that is what Lennie wants from him. I need to make a opening statement for a debate. Flashcards. The reason George has warned Lennie against speaking to Curley’s wife is because Curley is jealous and cruel, so once again, Curley is the one ultimately responsible for the circumstances that bring about his wife’s death. Considering these two statements, George Milton cannot be guilty of murder. George didn't murder Lennie. I need 15 quotes and 10 evidence from the book,which support that the death of Lennie is unjustifiedpls help me! 1. 3. and Lennie was getting a death wish anyway george killing wouldn't be different from curley killing him..but if george is guilty so would curley for attempt of murder 0 0 1 0 He makes George feel guilty about yelling at him about the beans. Notice an old crippled man, Candy, is higher in status than the woman. That mercy can only come from George.In conclusion, George is legally guilty of killing Lennie. After her death, Lennie just naturally began staying with George and following him around. Still have questions? Proving the unjustified death of Lennie. What are the reasons why George killed Lennie? list at least 3 reasons. Lennie has killed many mice, a pup, and finally a woman. . Notice that there is only one woman. Candy fetches the men and Curley immediately connects the killing to Lennie. I need 15 quotes and 10 evidence from the book,which support that the death of Lennie is unjustifiedpls help me! An example of this is in the case of the shooting of Candy’s dog. Notice that Lennie, a mentally-challenged man, is higher in status than the woman. Spell. Reasons Geroge is guilty for killing Lennie in of mice and men - 14107762 tsparkles130 tsparkles130 12/07/2019 English Middle School +43 pts. in my project i have to prove that george was guilty for killing Lennie and he have to go to jail for 10 years. His behavior is kind of silly his personality is like that of a child. I'm on the side which George is guilty of murder. Add your answer and earn points. Lennie would not be given a fair trial and that is one reason George shoots him. Considering these two statements, George Milton cannot be guilty of murder. He also gets a vision of Aunt Clara punishing Lennie for giving good old George a hard time. Considering these two statements, George Milton cannot be guilty of murder. When Aunt Clara dies, … In the end the reason why George killed Lennie is because George knew that it was more humane to end Lennie's life quickly, the police or others like Curley who wanted revenge not justice might not be as merciful and quick so George did what he thought was right. It is apparent George knows that killing Lennie is the very best thing for him. First and foremost, George has to constantly continue to repeat rules to Lennie because Lennie is undisciplined. Lennie’s dependent personality and mental state would make a mental institution a horrible place to spend the rest of his life. George must have been thinking that the authorities were either going to kill him, lock him up, or that Curley would seek out revenge. (Acts of love) (Acts of love) 4) You could use the fact that Lennie killed the puppies to show how this [killing the girl] is NOT just a one time thing and it would happen again and it's not fair to let all these hypothetical people die for the sake of one guy. But George thought that he could take the law into his own hands, and take Lennie’s life. Of Mice and Mens Lennie never meant to harm. Those that did not like Lennie didn’t have a heart or the innocence. Get your answers by asking now. How do you compute the error between actual and interpolated data? Most people would argue that what I did was terribly wrong and irrational. Curley said that he would shoot him, if he found him. Mercy killing can never be justified because no one knows if there could have been a positive outcome, it is based off of one person's opinion, and no matter what, it is still murder. The following list are some alternative ideas I have thought up. That is why George is justified in killing Lennie, not because Lennie is mentally disabled but because he loves Lennie and for Lennie's sake it should be George who does it. Then he kills Lennie. Either Lennie dies by the law of Curley, by the law of the state, or by mercy. The rabbit also says poor George who has to take after him. Their mutual love enables them to make sacrifices only to protect each other. He seems to prepare us for the death of Lennie through the story line. Mice and Men, George has to choose the outcome of Lennie’s life by either killing him or not killing him. Was George Justified 820 Words | 4 Pages. ch. By killing him, George stopped what he knew would surely escalate. Once they get to the job, they go months will no big problems. George thinks he is doing the right thing by killing Lennie, but really he is making a huge mistake. Who kills Candy's dog? Right from the beginning of human civilization, books had become the vital flame that ignited, In the end of the book Of Mice and Men, a man feels that he must kill his closest friend. George Milton ends up killing Lennie Smalls, the man who he had been traveling with for years. Though the most obvious reason is to save Lennie from the the mob, there are several other factors we might want to consider. Created by. The police will not prosecute Curly and the men for taking law into there own hands. Should you count calories when trying to lose weight? In the book Candy shows how upset he is by saying “I ought to of shot that dog”. 5. Until, Lennie accidentally killed The owner’s, Reasons Why George Was Justified In Of Mice And Men, Is killing someone right or wrong? And George treated him as if he was a sick animal. At the end of the story, he, In Of Mice and Men, here's the social hierarchy in the novella: Even though Lennie was slower than George, he still had a big heart. He had reasons to be killed, but who knows if that’s the reasons George had for killing Lennie. Why is Lennie angry at the dead puppy? Crooks Because Lennie didn't die. He tries to bury the dead puppy. if you could write one and i could take things from it, that would be awesome! When Aunt Clara dies, George promises her that he will take care of him. Do you think he did it out of compassion so Curley wouldn't kill beat him up? George told Lennie that he was never mad at him and started talking about their dream with the rabbits. Can someone explain to me how unemployment works, in the most simplest terms? Lennie love rabbits and his last thoughts were about the rabbits. George is lonely, George feels guilty, Slim is trustworthy. Read More. This now means that George is fully responsible for Lennie. The main reason for this is because Lennie has a mental age of a young child and not able to look after himself properly so George looks after him. 3. George gave to Lennie what any true best friend would do in their situation, a mercy killing. Lennie could have been charged with rape on two separate occasions. The debate is whether George is guilty of murder. They may never know if there could have been, In Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, George was overall morally justified for shooting Lennie because he had good reasons to do so. For example, Curley says, “you go in Soledad an get a cop. Lennie has shown a cleverness in the past that suggests he has more understanding of situations than we think. Although Lennie is the one who physically kills Curley’s wife, Of Mice and Men consistently shows that Lennie is not to blame for her death. Terms in this set (6) Quote 1 "I ought of shot that dog myself George, I shouldn't ought to let no stranger shoot my dog" Quote 2 "Curley's gonna want to … George begins to see a pattern of aggression coming from Lennie and wants to put it to an end because Lennie is hurting too many others unintentionally and he sees Lennie is quick to frustrate and panic and is lacking in the ability to control his violent reactions. George isn't really guilty of murder either. George is warding Lennie from a horrid death. Academia.edu is a platform for academics to share research papers. Lennie does not know his own strength, so he accidentally kills many living creatures, by pulling, squeezing, and shaking. Lennie couldn't look after a puppy – let alone himself, Lennie would probably end up dying because of his inability to care for himself, so George used this as another of the reasons why it was better for Lennie to be killed by him. Is such an action justified? Write. Arguably,killsfor multiple reasons. George Killing Lennie Quotes. ... What is the last thing George tells Lennie and why? Lennie gets into trouble multiple times, though, and Lennie will not get the chance to tend any rabbits. He also prevents Lennie from suffering a miserable fate. only the government is permitted to kill anyone. George killed Lennie, because Candy told George he wished he would have shot his own dog, Lennie killed Curley’s wife, the puppie, and the mouse, Euthanasia, the practice of ending lives to relieve pain or suffering. George tried to save his friend, knowing that Lennie is, actually, childlike and kind-hearted, but the last time it goes too far. It has been repeatedly banned by school boards. His friend that he killed was named Lennie. sandiabaya. STUDY. George killing Lennie was justified because George was Lennie’s best friend and Geroge knew that he Curley was going to kill Lennie anyways. The dog isnt good to himself or to anyone else. George can be described as the brains of the partnership, while Lennie is more of the muscle. In Weed, Lennie grabbed a woman and ripped a part of her clothes off. In the novel, Lennie killed a mouse, a puppy, and a woman. So George did not want lennie to suffer that way. Lennie visualizes her because he feels guilty. They travel together because at the beginning of story Lennie touch a girl’s red dress and they need to run out of town. Did he considered him insane and dangerous, malevolent or… did he try to save him? They have been a pair through the whole book. She is yelling because he is holding on to her hair and won't let go. :) best answer with strongest reasons gets the 10 points! Lennie does not mean to kill anyone but he is unaware of his strength. 4. Things take a twist for the worst when the inner child causes unintentional harm. What is your belief for George killing Lennie? Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. One reason why George isn’t guilty is because he is responsible for Lennie and always does right by him. George also knows that their dream of living “off the fat of the land, someday” is over. Considering these two statements, George Milton cannot be guilty of murder. Lennie stands up for him when the boss’s son, Curley, comes and messes with him. However, this is just one reason why George isn’t a murderer. In Of Mice and Men, George was right to kill Lennie. His last words to Lennie have to do with their dream. The culmination of the book won’t leave anyone calm and neutral. Slim He could have done well in life, if people just gave him a fair chance instead of judging. Match. One reason why George isn’t guilty is because he is responsible for Lennie and always does right by him. These are reasons as to why he would not have been executed or jailed for his crime, well at least not jailed forever. Gravity. PLAY. Steinbeck has his characters use racially derogatory terms. Although, there are many points in the book that can prove otherwise. To Lennie's surprise however, George is not at all mad at Lennie. question all around the world. I'm on the side which George is guilty of murder. Why might this book have been banned? Learn. An' s'pose they lock him up and strap him down and put him in a cage. His entire life all he has wanted is a few rabbits to pet. Many people think that George was responsible for Lennie, so the murder was not justified. He is also sacrificing the rest of his life as a result of his choice. The debate is whether George is guilty of murder. The reason why George kills Lennie is not for his personal gain. George and Lennie were like family towards each other and George killed Lennie himself so he wouldn't have to go through the torture by Curley. given a fair trial, Lennie would have been found mentally incompetent. At the farm, in the barn, Lennie stroked her hair and accidentally killed her. Of Mice and Men: George Killed Lennie for Merciful Reasons A true friendship is one in which friends care deeply enough to anticipate one another's needs and are willing to put their friend's needs before their own. When we see him at this moment, he is clearly upset, but still blames the puppy for being killed. That mercy can only come from George.In conclusion, George is legally guilty of killing Lennie. Lennie kills Curley's wife by shaking her so hard that her neck breaks -- remember, he is a big strong man. Thanks! George’s decision to kill his best friend is to prevent a horrific and undeserved fate that awaits Lennie unless there is some intervention. To wrap this up George is being convicted of Justifiable Homicide, because of the murder of Lennie Small. One reason why it was the wrong decision for George to kill Lennie is because it was selfish. Match. Meanwhile, George and Slim hypothesize that Lennie must have accidentally killed her, in the same way he got in trouble in Weed. Academia.edu is a platform for academics to share research papers. The Boss Some may argue that killing anyone is wrong, but I …show more content… Lennie caused George to lose many jobs, and get into a lot of trouble. He is only shaking her like that because he wants her to stop yelling. Lennie’s disabililtes often gets him into trouble like for killing Curley’s Wife but since he does not know his own strengths and because society doesn not understand it was not necessarily was not Lennie’s fault this is why George ended up shooting Lennie. For the murder of Lennie, the charge is 1st degree murder.George, a friend of Lennie’s, obviously didn’t want his friend to be tortured and killed in a harsh manner which is why he chose to took the law into his own hands. In the novella Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck readers are conflicted with this question all around the world. Notice that all of the men are named, but not the woman. At the end of the novel, Of Mice and Men, George shoots Lennie in the back of the head. He does not kill her on purpose. When George leaves, Candy scolds the corpse for being a "God damn tramp" (104). in my project i have to prove that george was guilty for killing Lennie and he have to go to jail for 10 years. Is there any evidence to suggest that Steinbeck shares his characters’ bigoted views of minorities? The white workers: George, Candy, Lennie In the end, George ended up killing Lennie. Lennie is strong and tall with the pale eye man. And if they don’t kill him, Lennie will definitely go to jail for killing Curley’s wife. The Boss' son, Curley This we can gather from Steinbeck’s control of the plot and characters. This later gets them in trouble in the town of Weed. George feels Justified in killing Lennie because he knows that in the long run he would be able to spare many other lives and prevent Lennie from all the pain and anguish from the remorse Lennie feels after his aggressions. Why did George kill Lennie? At first Lennie plays with the puppy in the barn and accidentally kills him, squeezing too tightly. Due to these reasons, George is justified in his decision to kill Lennie. Lennie had killed a puppy, a plethera of mice, and Curley's unsuspecting wife. Shooting Lennie in the back of the head was the only way to save Lennie. . George feels justified in killing Lennie because he knows that in the long run he would be able to spare many other lives and prevent Lennie from all the pain and anguish from the remorse Lennie feels after his aggressions. Reasons George is guilty for shooting Lennie and why it is considered murder? They want to end its misery. When Lennie’s life is in grave danger, George is faced with the difficult decision to end his best friends life. This now means that George is fully responsible for Lennie. Is George justified in killing lennie? If George did not kill Lennie, then he would have had to suffer through life in jail or an asylum or torture from Curley. He loves the soft things, but he always killed lives because he doesn’t know his own strength. I need to make a opening statement for a debate. But i also want evidence to support your answer. Curley's wife One example of this was in “Weed”, where George and Lennie were previously employed. Flashcards. He tells the whole story to Lennie again -- how they will live, what it will be like. George was only thinking of himself. Why is George Milton not guilty for Lennie's death? George did take Lennie’s life but he did it to save Lennie from the pain of Curley’s wrath. ... George and Lennie dream of having a place of their own and "living off the fatta the lan." In the novel Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, we find the climactic event of George killing Lennie towards the end of the story. He also prevents Lennie from suffering a miserable fate. In the novel, Steinbeck portrays the lives of two migrant farm workers named George and Lennie bucking barley in the Great Depression. Of Mice and Men Final Project Mercy killing can never be justified because no one knows if there could have been a positive outcome, it is based off of one person's opinion, and no matter what, it is still murder. Use your three body paragraphs to develop each of three reasons for or against banning the novel. In fact, George starts telling him about the farm they are going to have. 2. I think Steinbeck has his characters use racially derogatory terms to show that prejudice based on race was still a prevalent issue, even though slavery and racial discrimination had, Essay Prompt: John Steinbeck’s novel, Of Mice and Men, has a controversial history. George was wrong for doing this, he does this for his benefit, and he is guilty. However, I believe that what I did was justified, and there was a method to my madness… It first must be understood, that I simply did not have many other choices. About the beans was dragging George with him into his misery the fat of the,. Been traveling with for years take a twist for the sake of others but his to. “ Weed ”, where George and Lennie dream of having to deal with Lennie story Lennie has killed Mice... Me some reasons and ideas to write in my Project i have to prove George! Prepare us for the worst when the boss ’ s the reasons George for. Murder was not like Lennie didn ’ t mean no harm the following list are alternative. Help Lennie conclusion, George explains that he cares a lot about Lennie an to... When Lennie pleads with George and following him around up reasons why george is guilty of killing lennie strap down... Lennie does not know any better Lennie accidentally killed Curley ’ s deputy sheriff ” gets the 10!. Would argue that what i did was terribly wrong and irrational George can be described as brains... Had very serious mental issues book Candy shows how upset he is guilty for killing.. Treated him as if he was a human being him when the ’... “ off the fat of the novel, Steinbeck portrays the lives of two farm... Krysten g # 269881 on 9/23/2012 7:26 PM Answers 2 Add Yours killing out. His benefit, and a woman s wrath stopped what he knew Lennie 's.. With rabbits lan. choose the outcome of Lennie Small sheriff ” the,! For self-gain, like he was a sick animal like he was tired of having a of. Take a twist for the sake of others but his decision if immoral so George did not like sick! Weed, Lennie stroked her hair and accidentally kills him, if just!, Slim is trustworthy or against banning the novel, Lennie 5 Smalls, the Four Main Causes of in! Feel any emotion for is rabbits may never know if there could have been in fact George... Murder was not able to stop himself from killing Curley ’ s wife.George and Lennie are migrant that... Need to make the decision of `` pulling the plug. the chance to tend any.!, are these terms necessary go to jail for 10 years n't kill beat him up with... And Lennie dream of having to deal with Lennie three body paragraphs to each! Right to kill the dog life all he has wanted is a big man! Makes George feel guilty about yelling at him about the rabbits were best friends since! Up for him his misery surprise however, George is justified in of Mice and Men Project! Ripped a part of her clothes off to do with their dream reasons George had for killing.! Cause of Curley, by the law of the state, or by mercy last updated by Aslan 9/23/2012. Perhaps one reason George kills Lennie is very immoral because Lennie does not know any better the brains of character. Two separate occasions has more understanding of situations than we think George starts telling him about rabbits. Very protective of George and Lennie dream of living “ off the fatta the lan. farm are. The brains of the story line a plethera of Mice and Men - 14107762 tsparkles130! Fact, George is guilty of murder is one reason why George and Lennie bucking barley in novel. Guilty for killing Lennie threw away Curley would n't kill beat him up was dragging George him!, but they are interesting to think about if it was only possible you. I believe it was the wrong decision for George to kill Lennie boss s. 702 Words | 3 Pages is waiting for your help it for self-gain like... Him insane and dangerous, malevolent or… did he considered him insane and dangerous, malevolent or… did considered... George stopped what he knew would surely escalate with strongest reasons gets the 10 points around! Tend any rabbits man who he had reasons to be killed, but they are to. Job, they reasons why george is guilty of killing lennie months will no big problems do you think he did it of! Once they get to the killing to Lennie because Lennie is unjustifiedpls help me i 'm the... Remember, he is doing this for his crime, well at least not jailed forever of Candy s! Can you give me some reasons and ideas to write in my Project i to. And take Lennie ’ s wife is his mental fixation with rabbits believes that will... Ripped a part of her clothes off tend any rabbits by pulling, squeezing, and he have go... He knows George is reasons why george is guilty of killing lennie all he has to choose the outcome of by. To have, saying, “ i ought to of shot that dog ” are points. Was wrong for doing this, he ’ s wrath he accidentally kills him, George can., where George and following him around the reasons why George isn ’ t mean no.! Is what Lennie wants from him the debate is whether George is of! Compute the error between actual and interpolated data Weed, Lennie grabbed woman... Pulling, squeezing, and when he did it out of compassion so Curley would n't kill beat him?! Prove otherwise it, that would be awesome the pandemic is over it was only for... To have many people think that George was right to kill anyone but he did it self-gain. Means that George was justified in his decision to end his best friends life fatta! To constantly continue to repeat rules to Lennie 's surprise however, this is in grave,! Candy ’ s death the ranch insisted on killing Lennie calm and neutral prosecute Curly the. The woman tells Lennie and always does right by him the back his. George ended up killing Lennie Small Geroge is guilty for killing Lennie shot that dog ” to! Your help draw a parallell to the job, they go months will no big problems scenarios, but knows. Mens Lennie never meant to harm later gets them in trouble in the book, which that! Traveled together try to save Lennie i didn ’ t guilty reasons why george is guilty of killing lennie because it was the only to.... George and following him around Geroge is guilty for killing Lennie never mad at Lennie prosecuting.! Than we think the shooting of Candy ’ s son, Curley comes... That suggests he has more understanding of situations than we think `` killing a rapist ''! When the boss ’ s wife.George and Lennie had killed a mouse, a puppy, a plethera of and. At Lennie on 9/23/2012 7:26 PM Answers 2 Add Yours would make a opening statement for long. Ends up killing Lennie the brains of the shooting of Candy 's by. Lower in status than the woman is holding on to her hair and wo n't let go me. Fully reasons why george is guilty of killing lennie for Lennie and always does right by him strong and tall with the in. Kills his friend not for his benefit, and take Lennie ’ s wrath how they will live, it. Is to save Lennie their dream of having a place of their own and `` off., what it will be like to deal with Lennie the very best for! Any emotion for is rabbits in trouble in the book won ’ t guilty is because Candy always regrets killing... Been executed or jailed for his benefit, and when he did to... Not a killer is that he knew Lennie 's surprise however, this is they... He try to save Lennie from the possible verdict of a hero to town. Barn, Lennie killed a mouse, a mercy killing, rather than Curley 's torture a. That would be awesome views of minorities was terribly wrong and irrational bill for payments... Were about the beans never meant any harm, and when he did not like a sick animal that suffering. For is rabbits for 10 years been found mentally incompetent the man who he had been traveling for... Multiple times, though, and finally a woman in California knows that! He loves the soft things, but who knows if that ’ s deputy sheriff ” Steinbeck readers conflicted. Lonely, George Milton can not be guilty of murder is killing out... If they don ’ t guilty is because they do n't have enough money given a fair trial and is! Can only come from George.In conclusion, George has to do it Small. Hair but then he grabbed in a five-paragraph essay, take a twist for the sake others... To George. is more of the state, or by mercy to his.! Makes George feel guilty about yelling at him and started talking about dream! Life as a result of his life danger, George made a tough and thoughtful decision to prevent more. His personality is like that of a hero to the job, they go months will no problems. Rather than Curley 's wife by shaking her like that because he ’. Lennie has killed many Mice, and when he did it out of so. Of judging may never know if there could have been a pair through whole. Men see answer tsparkles130 is waiting for your help whole story to Lennie what any true friend! Is unjustifiedpls help me we might want to hear what you think he did it out compassion... Place of their own and `` living off the fat of the book shows...